Nov 17, 2026
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
MEDIA CONTACT: Haleemah Atobiloye (she/her) | Communications Strategist | haleemaha@cehn.org | (202) 350-1372
A federal judge found that the government violated the Endangered Species Act when it approved the November 19 auction without examining what mining would do to whales, sea turtles, sharks, and corals. Deep sea mining relies on unproven technology and threatens ecosystems scientists have barely begun to explore. We call on the Marine Minerals Administration to cancel the sale and listen to the people of American Samoa.
WASHINGTON, DC — On Monday, November 16, 2026, U.S. District Judge Jill Otake of the U.S. District Court for the District of Hawaiʻi ruled that the National Marine Fisheries Service violated the Endangered Species Act when it cleared the American Samoa Outer Continental Shelf Pacific Mineral Lease Sale 1 (PACM-1). The agency failed to consider the effects of mineral exploration and mining beyond the preliminary activities associated with the lease sale.
Communities deserve a healthy ocean and the power to shape their future. The proposed sale would offer more than 31 million acres of seabed off American Samoa. The waters at stake are home to several dozen protected species, including blue, fin, sei, and sperm whales; green, hawksbill, loggerhead, leatherback, and olive ridley sea turtles; oceanic whitetip and scalloped hammerhead sharks; giant manta rays; the chambered nautilus; and five species of coral. Scientists warn that seabed mining would destroy biodiversity in the deep sea before we even understand what exists within the seafloor habitats. Meanwhile, a new assessment of the technical and economic feasibility of deep sea mining in the American Samoa region casts serious doubt on whether seabed mining has any economic justification or viable future.
“This victorious ruling belongs to the people of American Samoa. For families in American Samoa, these harms reach into everyday life: the food they share, the livelihoods they sustain, and the cultural practices they pass on. The majority of the people said no from the beginning, they never wavered, and a court has now confirmed that the government did not do the work the law requires. We are glad they are able to keep building a future where the ocean continues to nourish families and traditions for generations,” says Shantha Ready Alonso, Executive Director, America the Beautiful for All Coalition.
“Our coalition will continue to stand in solidarity and use every tool available to us to protect the future this community wants, the health of local communities, and our ocean. We will stay in this fight until the threat of deep sea mining is lifted from the Pacific. We also congratulate Faʻasao Amerika Samoa, the Conservation Council for Hawaiʻi, Faleula o le Manuʻatele, Finafinau, and Earthjustice, whose leadership brought us here.”
This ruling is an important step, and our work continues. As of Tuesday, November 17, the Marine Minerals Administration (MMA) website still listed the auction for Thursday, November 19. MMA has a second lease sale proposed for December 16 off the Northern Mariana Islands, with the nearest lease area roughly 47 miles from Guam. That sale rests on the same kind of review the court just rejected.
Our ocean is not for sale.
Related Earthjustice statements: November 17 statement on the court ruling | October 19 challenge to leasing authority | August 18 endangered-species lawsuit
###
About Us
The America the Beautiful for All Coalition unites 300+ organizations across missions, ecosystems, communities, and cultures to steward nature while upholding environmental justice and defending public health. We follow the leadership of the communities closest to the lands, waters, and wildlife under threat.
