Nov 11, 2026
MEDIA CONTACT: Haleemah Atobiloye (she/her) | Program and Communications Strategist | haleemaha@cehn.org | (202) 350-1372
On Monday, November 9, 2026, the Senate voted 73–25 to advance the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA, S. 5653) toward debate.
We want to build AND protect, and this bill forces a false tradeoff between the two. A proposal to fix permitting should be able to explain what is broken. If consultation is causing delays, the evidence should show where. If a bill is expected to reduce emissions, the calculation should account for provisions that could increase them. If agencies are expected to work faster, they need the capacity to do so.
At our November 5 coalition-wide briefing, six experts from different fields examined historic preservation, Tribal water and land rights, clean water, endangered species, oceans, and public lands. As each presentation added to the last, a pattern emerged: the bill would narrow who participates, what agencies consider, what Tribal nation’s sovereignty is respected, and what communities can do when an approval violates the law. Provisions in different parts of the bill could reinforce one another, leaving the same communities with fewer opportunities to shape what happens where they live.
Our first piece, What the Senate Permitting Bill Means for Our Land, Water, Wildlife, and Communities, recaps the provisions our experts examined. Here, we explore what those connections teach us and what better permitting reform should protect.
We can and must do better: what we heard
Understand where the delays are. Speed is not the same thing as efficiency. Our speakers challenged the assumption that weakening environmental review and consultation would solve the problems holding projects up.
Charlie Thayer with the National Congress of American Indians presented federal data showing that the overwhelming majority of Section 106 reviews under the National Historic Preservation Act move forward without adverse effects. Where conflict arises, he explained, Section 106 gives no participant a veto. It brings people together to identify harm and find a way forward.
Jewel Tomasula with the Endangered Species Coalition described a similar pattern: many consultations conclude quickly, and the analysis she cited found no projects stopped through the consultations it examined. These findings give Congress reason to examine the diagnosis before removing protections. A shorter process is little help if it leaves the actual source of delay untouched.
Leave room to find a better outcome. Daniel Cordalis, an attorney with the Native American Rights Fund, asked us to consider the Klamath River. In reviewing whether to relicense a dam, what alternatives should agencies be allowed to consider? If every alternative must stay close to the original project’s purpose, he explained, removing the dam might never become an option.
His example showed what can be lost when review is judged only by how quickly it approves the proposal in front of it. The people who know a river may have reasons to question the continued presence of a dam; a useful process gives those reasons somewhere to go. Narrowing the alternatives an agency may consider can close off that possibility before the discussion begins.
Follow the consequences beyond the grid provisions. Transmission improvements matter to a clean energy future. So does the fossil fuel development that other parts of the bill could enable. Basia Marcks with Ocean Defense Initiative and Dan Hartinger with The Wilderness Society challenged the completeness of the emissions modeling used to present the bill as a climate win. They pointed to provisions that could lock in fossil fuel permits and grant approvals automatically when agencies miss deadlines, alongside changes affecting drilling and mining.
Basia also flagged provisions affecting industrial transmission rights of way in marine sanctuaries and environmental review of deep-sea mining. The bill’s climate benefits must be assessed alongside the development its other provisions could enable. Its consequences for oceans, public lands, and communities belong in the assessment, too.
Give participation the resources to work. Review takes people: staff who can assess evidence, preservation offices that can respond, and communities able to participate early enough to influence a proposal. State and Tribal preservation offices already work with chronically limited funding. Our briefing highlighted provisions that would allow the Interior Secretary to suspend that funding.
A demand for faster decisions should come with a commitment to the capacity needed to make them well. Better staffing, coordination, and early engagement offer a practical way to pursue efficiency and protection together.
What we are taking into our collective advocacy
These insights give us a clearer standard for reform: address the causes of delay, preserve the possibility of better outcomes, account for the full consequences, and give participation the resources to work. We are carrying that standard into our advocacy through three commitments.
Respecting Tribal sovereignty. Consultation and free, prior, and informed consent are different standards. Consent requires more than an agency completing a procedural step. We are carrying that distinction into our language and asks. Tribal Nations’ rights require more than inclusion in a general promise of public participation.
Listening to the people who know the places at risk. Rivers, canyons, coastlines, and communities are where the bill’s provisions would take effect. The people who know those places can explain what is at risk and what a better outcome would require. If this bill puts a place you care about at risk, we want to hear from you.
A commitment to building AND protecting. We need the grid and transmission infrastructure that can support a clean energy future. We can build it while respecting Tribal sovereignty, protecting waterways and public health, and keeping courts open when the law is broken. Permitting reform should help us meet those responsibilities. That is the standard we will keep asking Congress to meet.
Congress is making decisions about how our country will build. Those decisions should address actual delays, account for their full consequences, and protect the people who will live with the results. Our collective advocacy brings these responsibilities together.
We can and must do better. The Senate has advanced the bill, but it is not law. Please take action with us to remove its harmful provisions and demand better permitting reform.
###
About Us
The America the Beautiful for All Coalition unites 300+ organizations across missions, ecosystems, communities, and cultures to steward nature while upholding environmental justice and defending public health. We follow the leadership of the communities closest to the lands, waters, and wildlife under threat.
