Nov 9, 2026
MEDIA CONTACT: Haleemah Atobiloye (she/her) | Program and Communications Strategist | haleemaha@cehn.org | (202) 350-1372
At the center of our November 5 coalition-wide, cross-issue briefing on the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA, S. 5653) was one question: who gets to shape decisions about the lands and waters our communities depend on?
Permitting determines how an infrastructure project gets approved: who must be consulted, what evidence is considered, and what protections must be in place. It can feel distant until a data center, mine, or other large construction project is proposed near our homes, schools, or somewhere we care about.
At our coalition’s cross-issue briefing on Senate Permitting Bill briefing, six experts examined how BAAJA, as written, would narrow opportunities to shape approvals and limit remedies afterward. Across different laws, their presentations revealed a pattern: less meaningful participation, weaker protections, and harmful approvals that would be harder to revisit. Our speakers expanded our understanding of what permitting is for. It is not only a process for getting projects approved quickly, it is also our public responsibility to make equitable decisions about infrastructure, rights, land, water, and consequences that can last generations.
What it means for the places we love and call home
Sacred and historic places. For Tribal Nations, the stakes include sovereignty, sacred places, and the federal government’s obligations to consult. Charlie Thayer, our expert from the National Congress of American Indians walked us through Section 2301, which would rewrite the National Historic Preservation Act. He described provisions that would make consultation effectively optional, impose a rigid 30-day response window, and exempt whole categories of projects. The changes would also affect what counts as harm. Agencies could set aside visual and audible impacts, a consequential omission for places whose significance extends beyond the precise patch of ground where construction occurs.
Safe and clean water. A similar narrowing appeared in the water provisions. Kristine Oblock with Clean Water for All explained how Sections 1201–1205 would restrict states’ and Tribal Nations’ ability to consider fish passage, aquifer recharge, cultural practices, and water affordability when reviewing permits. These are different ways people and ecosystems depend on water. Excluding them would leave important effects of a project outside the review. Water pollution permits would also run for ten years instead of five, lengthening the interval between opportunities to update permit conditions as communities and water conditions change.
Daniel Cordalis, from the Native American Rights Fund, also shared what narrowing review could mean for the Klamath River. If dam relicensing review could consider only alternatives closely aligned with the original project’s purpose, he explained, dam removal might never have been on the table. What a review allows agencies to consider can shape the future of a river and the communities that depend on it.
Wildlife. Decisions must often be made with evidence that is strong but incomplete. Jewel Tomasula, our expert from the Endangered Species Coalition, explained how the bill’s proposed definition of “best available science” could turn ordinary scientific uncertainty into a reason to deny protection. The change would reach species listing, delisting, critical habitat, and project reviews. Using sea otters as an example, Jewel explained how their vulnerability to oil spills helped establish the case for protection. Under the bill’s proposed definition, she warned, that protection wouldnot have been secured. Species threatened by climate change would face particular difficulty. The question is how to act responsibly on the evidence available while there is still time to prevent harm.
Oceans and coasts. The consequences extend offshore. Basia Marcks of Ocean Defense Initiative highlighted language affecting industrial transmission rights of way in marine sanctuaries, deep-sea mining, and environmental review of activities outside U.S. territory. She warned that projects in international waters could proceed without review even when their impacts reach U.S. coastal communities. The people affected by a decision may live far beyond the place where it is made.
What happens after approval
As written, BAAJA would also limit what governments and communities can do after a permit is granted. The stakes become greater when an approval is difficult to revisit.
Locked-in permits. Basia described the bill’s Project Certainty provisions, which would restrict a future administration’s ability to revoke, suspend, or amend permits. Missed review deadlines could trigger automatic approval, including when reviewing agencies are understaffed and underfunded. Developers could also seek construction costs and punitive damages from taxpayers over claims of “disparate treatment” in permitting. These provisions would give an initial decision lasting force, even as evidence, conditions, or public priorities change.
Access to courts. The bill would shorten the time available to challenge approvals and limit the remedies courts could provide. Communities could succeed in showing that an approval violated the law while construction continued as the agency addressed the deficiency. A legal victory would not necessarily stop the harm that prompted the challenge.
Public lands. Dan Hartinger, our speaker from The Wilderness Society brought those consequences into focus through the Greater Chaco region in New Mexico. Pueblo and Tribal advocacy helped secure a mineral withdrawal protecting 336,000 acres of public lands surrounding Chaco Culture National Historical Park. The Trump administration is now moving to rescind that protection. Dan explained how the bill could make the next steps harder to reverse. Oil and gas leases issued after the withdrawal is removed could be protected from cancellation by a future administration. Courts could be barred from vacating approvals found to violate the National Environmental Policy Act or the National Historic Preservation Act, and drilling could continue while agencies corrected legal deficiencies.
What we are asking Congress to protect
The cumulative lesson of our briefing was that meaningful participation requires more than an invitation to speak. It requires a process in which evidence-based knowledge can influence the outcome, governmental obligations are honored, and unlawful decisions can be meaningfully challenged.
This is why we reject the false choice between building and protecting. We need the grid and transmission infrastructure that can support a clean energy future. We need decisions that respect Tribal sovereignty. We need safeguards for the lands, waters, wildlife, and well-being our communities and futures depend on.
We can build AND protect. Congress should insist on both.
In part two, What We Learn When We Go Beyond Interpreting BAAJA Title by Title, we explore what these connections teach us and what we are carrying forward.
Watch the full briefing:
Take action:

###
About Us
The America the Beautiful for All Coalition unites 300+ organizations across missions, ecosystems, communities, and cultures to steward nature while upholding environmental justice and defending public health. We follow the leadership of the communities closest to the lands, waters, and wildlife under threat.
